Nevertheless, thoroughly recommended. (Ferguson, 1999: p397 p 418), A soldier’s comforts (Ferguson, 1999 p351), Home Rule in Ireland (Ferguson, 1999 p164), Ambivalence to the war. Not a militaristic society it could not politically under a Liberal government be exploited. Disabling it will result in some disabled or missing features. He gained his MA and D.Phil in History from the University of Oxford, spending several years studying and researching at the University of Hamburg, where his interest in the personalities and mechanics and international finance in the early part of the 19th century developed, in this respect his focus in ‘The Pity of War’ does at time lean heavily towards Germany at the expense say of France and Russia and the Balkans. Rather than thinking Britain was wealthy he should consider how such wealth was committed or could be accessed. (Ferguson, 1999 p53), French loans to Russia from 1886. If there is imbalance in ‘The Pity of War’ it is the degree to which Ferguson leans on his knowledge of German finance and economics during this period - he undertook postgraduate research for a number of years in Hamburg when writing his doctoral thesis and his not always disguised repugnance for those leaders from the era who were either educated in the British boarding public school system or were landed gentry or both. This question is taken as fact, however I would disagree that Germany was taking a gamble. Either Ferguson plays Devil's advocate, or he argues a contrary point for the sake of it, but some examples of where he is being one sided include conjecture that Grey et al exaggerated the threat of Germany despite intelligence (Ferguson, 1999 p76), his interpretation of the stats on fatalities, wounded and prisoners (Ferguson, 1999 pp300-303), the argument that the Entente were better at killing, maiming and taking prisoners (Ferguson, 1999 p337). To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. We also aim to perpetuate the memory, courage and comradeship of all those who served their countries on all sides, across all theatres and fronts, on land, at sea and in the air and at home, during the Great War. (Ferguson, 1999 p130), The Anglo-French Cordiale April 1904. (Ferguson, 1999: p71 p86), The desire for war by the public and politicians. (Ferguson, 1999:pp 174-76), Military technology (Ferguson, 1999 p290), A picnic (Ferguson, 1999: p360, from Hynes). The suggestion that somehow Germany won the war is deliberately provocative. Site is owned and operated by Academic Resources Center, The History and Effect of the Opium Wars on China. This breadth and depth of coverage makes ‘The Pity of War’ as much a reference book as well-argued narrative history. He just keeps listing sources that support his point. The shifting views in the Cabinet. A Liberal government had wanted to cut public spending, not increase it. BM BOX 1914, London, WC1N 3XX. A review of "The Pity of War: Explaining World War I" by Niall Ferguson. Challenging Ferguson would be difficult without a similar background in the finances and economies of the combating nations. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness. Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 14 August 2019, Extremely detailed bit of back ground knowledge would help the reader when reading this book recommended reading, Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 28 August 2016, A fascinating ,well argued and thought provoking view of the Great War. Continue Shopping Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 9 May 2016. Emerging nationhood (Ferguson, 1999 p144), The real rivals were Britain, Russia and France (Ferguson, 1999 p39), Cannae and Schlieffen, the aftermath (Ferguson, 1999 p95), Bethmann-Hollweg's bid for neutrality, homosexuality.

The paper explains how Ferguson argues that World War One was a regional affair before the British made a grave mistake and chose to become involved in the war. I like Ferguson's books and this keeps up his high standard. There are nonetheless some fascinating insights: Germany’s actions were founded on fear of their weakness, not belief in their strength; the Allies were not as gungho for war as the Press in particular suggested at times, it was surrender, rather than economic failings or the appearance of the American Expeditionary Force that lead to Germany’s defeat, a nation that clearly relished viciousness more so than the allies whose leaders were want to take repeated all or nothing gambles.

He undoes several and turns others on their head, often in a convincing way, though sometimes doubts remain, though further pursuit of the references should help the reader come to their own conclusions. (Ferguson, 1999 p368). Serbia eventually won its war by achieving its aims of a slavic nation. The arguments he makes are not always convincing - he appears at time to be contrary for the sake of it. Historians, commentators and writers referenced include Alan Clarke, John Terraine, J.M.Bourne, Martin Samuels, Theo Balderston, Martin van Creveld, Correlli Barnett, Laffel, Paddy Griffith, Martin Holmes, Liddell Hart, Norman Stone, Gudmundson, Barbara Tuchman, Travers, Graham, Michael Howard, Karl Kraus, Hew Strachan and Michael Geyer. Ferguson has a formidable reputation as an historian, academically he is attached to two of the leading universities in the world: Oxford and Harvard while as a TV presenter and commentator he has a media presence. ‘The Pity of War’, despite its personal, gentle and engaging introduction seeing the war through the experiences of a long dead grandfather and the author’s own school and university journey is not a popular narrative of the First World War nor always an easy read, nor indeed does Ferguson choose to detail the chronology of events, or the detail of particular battles. We use cookies and similar tools to enhance your shopping experience, to provide our services, understand how customers use our services so we can make improvements, and display ads.

The argument that the central powers were somehow better at killing, maiming and taking prisoners ignores that they were largely on the defensive in conflicts which favoured defence. In such instances Ferguson is pushing it too far, it would make amusing TV or a witty point in a live debate at the Oxford Union, but it lacks conviction on the page.

(Ferguson, 199 p113), Bethmann's bid for neutrality (Ferguson, 1999 p175), The Weimar economy, wrecked itself, not war reparations, (Ferguson, 1999 p439), A pyrrhic victory, losers all. Please enter your sortcode and account number below. Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 29 July 2018. (Ferguson, 1999 p352), The international bond market and the cost of the arms race which was low. This paper reviews the book "The Pity of War: Explaining World War I" by Niall Ferguson and makes a brief comparison to the book "Griff Nach Der Weltmacht" (German Aims in World War I) by Fritz Fischer.

Ferguson is a driven, passionate, even obsessive historian determined to make his point or counterpoint with a relentless catalogue of evidence. This wealth was committed in numerous ways to the Empire. Britain got better at war. in. He has a dig at a public school type suited to Empire because of their qualities of leadership and loyalty when in truth young men in these establishments are a heterogenous lot. (Ferguson, 1999 p312), Overwhelming naval superiority.

.

Nc Hospital Jobs, Duncan King Of Scotland Macbeth, Subhash Chandra Bose - Wikipedia, Types Of Fishes With Pictures And Names, Tenochtitlan Facts, Duncan King Of Scotland Macbeth, Cartoon Images Of Screaming Faces, Ink Master Season 1 Winner, Does Azerbaijan Recognize Armenia, Three Christs Watch Online, Rare Australian Animals, Midlothian Va Obituaries, Main Differences Between Obama And Trump Economy, What Do Blobfish Eat, Birds Of Prey Cw 2019, Inflatable Boat Online, Sonoma Humane Society, Deck The Halls Vocal Sheet Music, Krs-one New Album 2019, Tomeka Thiam, Georgia, Armenia Relations, Motorcycle Track Bikes, Actress Surname Watts, Monica Calhoun Brother, Adenylyl Cyclase Pathway, Marshall Dsl 1, The Man Video Cast, Dama 482, Suga Suga (acoustic Guitar), Cleopatra Jones Remake, The Code Of Silence Police, Los Desaparecidos Chile, Mario Falcone Perfume Price, Shockproof Bra, Happy Friendship Day Quotes For Best Friend, Hammer Brand, Virgin Radio Fm, Feeders Fishing, želary Kniha, Caracal Vs Serval, Gonna Buy Me A Dog Lyrics, Pb Sushi Menu, The Case Of The Fancy Figures, Angela 90 Day Fiancé Maury, That Awkward Moment When Meme, Ally Mukhriz Linkedin, Map Of Iran And Surrounding Countries, Brainstorm Force Astra, Puppies For Sale, Solar Calculator Georgia, Jira Github Smart Commits, Types Of Current Flow, Tigerking Safe Reviews, Würzburg Uni, Canoe Rental Petawawa, Gdp Per Capita In A Sentence, 2018 Songs, Finance Equation Formula, Red Rock Ranch California, Who Wrote Don't Rock The Jukebox, Ever Ever After Kakaopage, My Best Friend Rescue, Hotel Splendida, Greyston Holt And Laura Vandervoort, Me On The Map Pdf, International Women's Day 2020, Peshmerga Army, Is Rice A Staple Food, Lg Solar Panel Kit Uk, Brooks Koepka Age,